Family-owned independent agency · Chappaqua, NY · Since 1929 info@nicolaysenagency.com  ·  Hours: Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm
Nicolaysen Agency Insurance · Since 1929

Home / About Us

About Us

Chappaqua's hometown insurance agency, since 1929

Family owned and serving Chappaqua and the Greater NY Metro for generations, with a steadfast commitment to being the trusted local insurance professional.

Our Story

Four generations of family values

Founded in 1929 by Erik Nicolaysen II, Nicolaysen Agency has been the hometown insurance agency for Chappaqua, NY, serving both personal and commercial clients.

Erik's son, Erik Nicolaysen III, went to work with his father after receiving an Engineering Degree at Rutgers University and serving in the United States Army in Korea. Erik assumed managerial operations in 1970. In the mid-1970s, Erik tore down the original building and put his engineering degree to work building the current office building in the same location. Erik greatly expanded the agency during his tenure, and he never lost sight of his father's dedication to the community, the importance of exceptional service, and a steadfast commitment to being "the" trusted local insurance professional.

Today, Erik's grandson Bryan runs the day-to-day operations and has built a team that is taking the agency to the next level. From technological upgrades to in-house builder/developers, Bryan has modernized operations while expanding expertise in high-value personal lines and specialty commercial coverage. This forward-thinking approach ensures we remain agile in a changing world, all while upholding the family values that have defined us for generations.

As we approach our centennial, Nicolaysen Agency continues to be more than an insurance provider. We are your neighbors, your advocates, and your partners in protection. Rooted in a long history of trust, integrity and personalized service, we look forward to serving Chappaqua and the greater community for many years to come.

From Our Archives

Nearly a century on Greeley Avenue

Black-and-white photo of the original Nicolaysen real estate and insurance office
The original office, on the same lot as today's building.
Black-and-white photo of Erik Nicolaysen II seated at a desk with Erik Nicolaysen III and a colleague
Erik Nicolaysen II (center) and Erik Nicolaysen III (right).
Black-and-white photo of Erik Nicolaysen II and Erik Nicolaysen III standing by a desk in the office with a colleague seated at a typewriter
Erik Nicolaysen II (left) and Erik Nicolaysen III (center) in the office.
Black-and-white photo of two agency staff members at work, one on the telephone at her desk
Agency staff at work in the office.

Our Team

Meet the team

97 years later, Nicolaysen Agency is still run by the Nicolaysen family.

Bryan Nicolaysen, Principal

Bryan Nicolaysen

Principal

Erik Nicolaysen III, President

Erik Nicolaysen III

President

Kyle Nicolaysen, Chief Operations Officer

Kyle Nicolaysen

Chief Operations Officer

Joshua Breitmaier

Joshua Breitmaier

Ariana Hurtado

Ariana Hurtado

Danielle Carlson-Murphy

Brett Saso

Brett Saso

Work with a local agency that knows you

Stop by 77 S Greeley Ave., call, or book a time that works for you.