Insuring Chappaqua, New York, & Beyond
About Us
As independent agents in Chappaqua, NY, we work for you—not the insurance companies. We match you with trusted carriers to protect against risk and ensure fair claims support. Our focus is on personalized service, strong relationships, and reliable coverage you can count on.
Established 1929
COMPANIES WE REPRESENT
Chubb
•
Pure
•
Travelers
•
Hanover
•
National General
•
Encompass
•
Selective
•
Kemper
•
Hartford
•
MassMutual
•
NYCM
•
Sterling
•
Guardian
•
NYSIF
•
Chubb • Pure • Travelers • Hanover • National General • Encompass • Selective • Kemper • Hartford • MassMutual • NYCM • Sterling • Guardian • NYSIF •
Our Services
More options, better coverage. We shop multiple trusted insurers to find the right auto policy for your lifestyle and budget.
Protect your future with a plan that fits your needs. As independent agents, we compare top carriers to find long-term care coverage that works for you.
Your home deserves the right protection. We work with a range of providers to tailor coverage to your property and needs.
Every business is different—your coverage should be too. We partner with top insurance carriers to customize protection for your unique risks.
Real Feedback from Real Clients
-
![]()
"I have been using Nicolaysen Insurance Agency for 39 years for home and auto insurance, now just auto. That should be enough endorsement. I have always found them helpful."
William Davis
-
![]()
"We've had a great experience dealing with Randy and the staff at Nicolaysen! We've insured multiple cars and houses with him, and he is always easy to reach, efficient in getting our concerns addressed and pleasant to deal with. "
Elena Pousada
-
![]()
"Everyone in the office is very helpful, and when I had a major claim after my car was totaled a couple of years ago, I got my payout quickly and with no fuss."
Brad Kelly
-
![]()
"The people at Nicolaysen are not only knowledgeable and responsive, but also genuinely caring. Randy, Marion, Lillian... they all go above and beyond to help, whatever the need. Very grateful for their coverage."
Josh Bieber
-
![]()
"I've been a client for 31 years. Never have they taken the expeditious route instead of the right way. Quality of service and product has always been in my best interest."
Lester Himel
-
![]()
"I love working with Nicolaysen agency. They are always friendly and helpful and have made suggestions to save me money whenever possible."
Vickie Savanella
Contact Us
We're here to help. Whether you're looking for coverage options, need support with your policy, or just want to learn more, send us a message and our team will get back to you as soon as possible.